Seafood Choices: Tradeoffs between Omega-3 and Mercury
On EWG web site, it has published a report on seafood choices. We eat fish or shellfish for the benefits of omega-3s.[1] However, seafood are also high in mercury.[4] Therefore, we need to choose fish based on its omega-3 and mercury levels. Depending on your age, weight, and gender, EWG makes the following recommendations on what kinds of seafood to eat or avoid. Calculation are based on 4 oz. serving size. Note that sustainability is also considered in EWG's recommendations, which is based on the Seafood Watch from Monterey Bay Aquarium.[2,6]
: Very High Omega-3s, Low Mercury, Sustainable
: High Omega-3s, Low Mercury
: Low Mercury But Also Low Omega-3s
: Mercury Risks Add Up (Pregnant Women And Children Should Limit Or Avoid)
: Avoid (Mercury Levels Too High To Eat Regularly)
This article was based on a report from EWG.[3]
| Species |
Weekly Mercury |
Sustainability |
Max Servings per Week |
| Salmon | 13% | Best Choice: Wild Alaska | 3 |
| Sardines | 20% | Best Choice: Pacific | 3 |
| Mussels | 8% | Best Choice: farmed | 3 |
| Rainbow Trout |
13% | Best Choice: farmed | 3 |
| Atlantic Mackerel |
10% | Best Choice: Not Trawled | 3 |
| Pollock/ Imitation Crab |
15% | Good Alternative* | 3 |
| Shrimp | 8% | Variable* | 3 |
| Tilapia | 5% | Best Choice: Equador, U.S., Canada | 3 |
| Catfish | 5% | Best Choice: Farmed U.S. | 3 |
| Scallops | 10% | Good Alternative* | 3 |
| Pangasius (Swai, Basa, Tra) |
5% | Good Alternative | 3 |
| Clams | 8% | Best Choice | 3 |
| Canned Light Tuna |
31% | Variable* | 3 |
| Flatfish (Plaice, Sole, Flounder) |
31% | Good Alternative* | 3 |
| Orange Roughy |
145% | Avoid* | 0 |
| Shark | 224% | Avoid* | 0 |
| Swordfish | 227% | Variable* | 0 |
: Very High Omega-3s, Low Mercury, Sustainable
: High Omega-3s, Low Mercury
: Low Mercury But Also Low Omega-3s
: Mercury Risks Add Up (Pregnant Women And Children Should Limit Or Avoid)
: Avoid (Mercury Levels Too High To Eat Regularly)Acknowledgement
This article was based on a report from EWG.[3]
References
- Omega-3 Fatty Acids (Travel and Health)
- Seafood Watch 2013 (Travel to Wellness)
- EWG’s Consumer Guide to Seafood: Executive Summary
- Mercury Exposures and Autoimmune Diseases (Travel to Wellness)
- Study: Mislabeled shrimp at restaurants, grocers
- Oceana said it found about 30 percent of 143 shrimp products bought from 111 vendors were not what the label said.
- There Aren’t Plenty of Fish in the Sea
Comments
Post a Comment